Aquaponics is the raising of fish and plants in recirculating systems whereby the fish provide nutrients to the plants and the beneficial bacteria and plants help to return the water clean to the fish. It’s a highly productive eco-system with many extraordinary benefits, most notably its ability to conserve water with minimal if any discharge. While there is plenty of information out there about the benefits of aquaponics, let’s talk about some specifics regarding system design that could be particularly important for mitigating some of the risks and challenges often found with aquaponics. To provide some context and scale, I’m using our farm which occupies a 3,200 sq ft greenhouse. However, these ideas are applicable to any scale system.
Our aquaponics farm is designed to run in a “de-coupled” mode whereby the fish system can be operated independently of the hydroponic plant system. In normal operation, the water from the fish tanks flow through a series of filtration tanks and then out into the hydroponic system. A single pump returns this filtered clean water back to the fish system. In de-coupled mode, water from the fish tanks flows through the filtration system as it does in normal operation but it does not pass into the hydroponic troughs, it returns via a separate line back to the fish tanks. The filtration or life support system (LSS) is designed to provide the proper mechanical and biological filtration necessary to support appropriate water quality for the fish.
When the fish system is running on its own loop, the hydroponic system can also continue flowing via its own pump. In our farm, water pumps from the last deep water culture trough back to the first trough maintaining continuous flow through all four troughs.
Why decouple the system? Having the capability to isolate systems is important for a number of reasons. First and foremost, I don’t know any fish farmer (amateur or experienced) who hasn’t lost a good majority of their fish population at one point or another. Reasons for catastrophic fish deaths or illness can often be attributed to:
- Power failures and a lack of good backup, monitoring and alerting systems.
- Loss of water due to a blockage, overflow, rupture or operator error.
- Poor temperature control and water quality management. Variability in temperature can be highly stressful on fish and if you are not able to properly control temperature, fish may stop eating. If your fish stop eating this affects the nutrient dynamics in your system.
- Fish disease can also creep up quickly if the temperature, water quality and health of the fish are not being regularly monitored or you are not quarantining fish upon arrival from other sources.
Other reasons for having a decoupled system can include the fact that you can cycle your fish system independently while having plants growing in your hydroponic system. Or perhaps you started as a hydroponic grower and you are adding on an aquaculture component later in the cycle. Another popular design is to have your fish system in a separate facility or “head house” and your plants in a greenhouse. The systems can still be hydraulically connected so that fish water can be delivered to the plant system but may not necessarily return to the fish house.
Another advantage is that the hydroponic troughs (DWC) can be run at their own flow rate if so desired. In other words, when the fish and plant system is running together in normal operating mode using a single pump, the hydroponic pump could be used to circulate water at a variable flow rate through the DWC troughs as well. This requires the running of two pumps, but if increasing flow rate in the hydroponic troughs is desirable than the separate DWC pump and plumbing gives the operator the ability to do so. This could be beneficial in case water flow rates are too low through the troughs.
As is often the case in commercial aquaponics, the majority of the revenue is in the plants so having your plant system entirely dependent on your fish system creates a single point of failure scenario which can be avoidable in a decoupled system. If you have an issue with your fish system for any of the reasons cited above or more, you can still continue to run your hydroponic system on an organic nutrient solution so that you are able to maintain your production crop, your customers and revenue stream.
When reconnecting the two systems, it will be important to ensure ammonia and nitrites have been fully oxidized and are at safe levels for the fish. Water temperature, pH, Alkalinity and other factors affecting water quality may not be properly aligned between the fish and plant system so adjustments to these levels may be necessary to make a seamless transition and minimize stress on your fish. There may also be other elements of the hydroponic nutrient solution that could be problematic for fish at certain levels. For example we raise hybrid striped bass which are sensitive to potassium. It is always important to do your homework when you are considering adding something to your aquaponics environment. Thinning out the solution and exchanging with fresh water may be required to help reduce any potential toxicity and allow you to safely reconnect both environments.
Does it mean that in a de-coupled system, the plants will not benefit from the nutrients from fish water which is the whole point of an integrated fish-plant system? and instead need to depend on external fertiliser food?
Not necessarily. There are a few scenarios here. One in which you do have complete decoupling whereby you provide the plants an organic hydroponic nutrient solution. This is usually only the case for temporary periods of time where your fish population and nutrient load is not adequate to supply the plants. This often happens during the initial startup phase of a farm where you don’t have your total population of fish available yet. Otherwise you would want to run in coupled mode as much as possible to take advantage of the fish nutrients.
The second decoupled scenario is one where you periodically draw nutrients from the fish system and dose them into a nutrient reservoir which can then be circulated through the plant system. However, the water from the plant system does not return back to the fish. So you are basically running your plant system independently but you are dosing with fish water and then replacing the fish water with fresh water as needed to top up the fish system.
Hi. I understand the advantages of decoupling, but was wondering about nutrient concentration in the cycling loop from fish tank(s) to filter and back to the fish. Wouldn’t cycling water back to the fish tank eventually lead to increased loads of nitrates in that loop even though all of the solids are being diverted towards the plant loop? Many thanks
In normal operation we are running as a coupled system, taking advantage of the continuous supply of nitrates from the fish and returning the water back to the fish after it has flowed through the plant system. When running decoupled it is assumed that you are still drawing nutrient rich water off the fish system and dosing your plant system with it but not returning the water back to the fish. In that case you would need to be providing fresh water exchange into the fish system to compensate for the water taken out. This is one aspect to managing the water quality and elevated nitrates in the fish system specifically. Elevated nitrates are not typically an issue under 400ppm relative to their more toxic counterparts, nitrite and ammonia. In a typical RAS system with no plants it is common practice to perform regular water exchanges generally around 6 to 10% of the total system volume each month to control nitrate accumulation. This also depends on your stocking density, feed rate, bio filter performance etc…
Enjoyed reading this, very informative. Thank you
Hello, really interesting read. I have a question about using wastewater nutrients from the fish rearing tanks as nutrients for the hydroponic component. I’ve never set up a hydro or aquaponics system before so my understanding isn’t great. When first setting up a decoupled aquaponics system, do you initially fill the hydroponics compartment with fresh water and then periodically add nutrient wastewater from the fish rearing tanks. And when you do add water from the fish rearing tanks, how much water should you add to the hydroponics compartment? I’m assuming the wastewater is not super nutrient-dense, so when it is added to the hydroponics compartment of the system won’t it be incredibly diluted?
Most of our systems operate using auto-toppers so fresh filtered water added to the fish sump. The plant sump when decoupled will autofill from the fish sump or other source, depending on your design. As for nutrients our clients like that they can immediately start growing in their systems using organic nutrients like Espartan. Once the system has a full fish load they can decrease and eventually remove Espartan and either run their system coupled or continue decoupled. Dilution isn’t an issue, when the fish are small you can just test the water in both your fish system and plant system and make adjustments.
I hope this answered your question.
Hey, thanks for the read. In hydroponics, it is recommended to change out the nutrient solution. With decoupled Aquaponics would it be necessary to be changing out the hydroponic beds water? Or can you leave the same water in and keep dosing with your nutrients from the fish to maintain adequate nutrients for the plants?
Hello, Thank you for the question. You leave the same water in a deep water culture system. The decoupled beds get their water automatically using a simple autotopper. In addition, you can safely add specific nutrients to the beds.